Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Definition

Anecdotal evidence is a type of evidence that relies on personal experience or observation.  It occurs when an individual’s anecdote is used to support a claim about the population as a whole. Anecdotal evidence is when you tell a story about an event that happened to you.

This type of evidence is usually not considered very reliable because it’s based on one person’s experience and can’t be verified by other people.

One example of anecdotal evidence fallacy is when people use their own personal experiences to make a point about an entire group. Another example of anecdotal evidence fallacy occurs when someone uses one anecdote as proof for a generalization.

For example, if someone tells me they had a really bad day at work, I would ask them for more details about what caused this bad day and how often they have these types of days.

Another example of this would be if someone claimed that all students in their high school were required to wear uniforms because they had seen one student wearing a uniform.

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Examples

Anecdotal Evidence example in Philosophy

Examples of Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Philosophy:

The anecdotal evidence fallacy occurs when a person uses an anecdote as evidence for a claim.

For example, if someone claims that all dogs are friendly and then tells you about their friend’s dog who is friendly, they have committed the anecdotal evidence fallacy.

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Real-Life Examples

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Real Life:

•  When I was a kid, my dad told me that your skin would turn orange if you eat too many carrots.
•  My friend’s cat is always hungry, and he eats everything in sight
• The other day when I was walking home from school, this guy came up to me and asked for money
• My friend told me that they saw a UFO last night
•  I was watching the news, and they said that there’d been an increase in crime lately.
•  I heard this on NPR

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Examples in Media

Examples of Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Media: 

The media often reports on anecdotal evidence.  Anecdotal evidence is a personal experience that may or may not be representative of the whole population.

When an article cites anecdotal evidence, it can be difficult to tell what’s true and what isn’t

Another example of anecdotal evidence in the media would be a news story about how someone was robbed at gunpoint and then blamed on immigrants.

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Examples in Advertising

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Advertising:

• The ad for a new weight loss product that claims to have “scientifically proven” results.
• A testimonial from someone who lost 50 pounds in just 3 weeks.
•  An advertisement for an acne medication with before and after pictures

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Politics

Examples of Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Politics:

Anecdotal evidence is often used to back up claims that are not supported by statistics.  For example, if a politician says, “I have met many people who feel like they’re being ignored,” this may be anecdotal evidence for the claim that people feel ignored.

However, it’s possible that the politician has only met a small number of people and their feelings are not representative of everyone.

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy examples in Movies

Examples of Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Movies:

The movie is about a man who’s in love with his best friend’s wife. This is an example of anecdotal evidence fallacy because one person told the story, and it can’t be verified as truth

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Examples in Literature

Examples of Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in Literature:

• The author had a dream about the protagonist’s father, so it must be true.
• A character is described as having red hair and green eyes; therefore, this describes all people with red hair and green eyes.
•  One person said that they saw someone who looked like their friend at the mall, so they’re probably together.

Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy Examples in News

Examples of Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy in News:

•  An article about a new study that says eating cheese will make you live longer
• A story on how their pet dog saved someone’s life
•  A news report about a woman who survived an attack because she was wearing her seatbelt

Some Related articles:

• 7 Motte and Bailey Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

• 11 Examples of Pathetic Fallacy in Frankenstein, Macbeth, Movies & Literature

• 9 Missing the Point Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads