Is-Ought Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

Is-Ought Statistics Fallacy

Is-Ought Fallacy Definition

The is ought fallacy is when someone assumes that what they want to be true should also be true. This fallacy can happen when people are trying to convince others of their opinion, or if they are trying to justify an action.

There are two types of this fallacy- the first type is where a person tries to say that something has happened because it ought to have happened and the second type happens when someone says that something ought not have happened because it didn’t happen

Ought fallacy is a logical fallacy that is derived from the word ought. Logically, the word ought means to be desirable or an obligation. The ought fallacy is committed when one person argues that because something is what it ought to be, it is actually what it ought to be.

The is-ought fallacy is the idea that a person can’t make a moral judgment on a situation because they’re not an omnipotent being with knowledge of the future. They might say that “I can’t say that a certain thing is wrong because I don’t know what the future will bring.” But this is nonsensical because the true test of a moral judgment is what people think about it in the present, not what someone can think about it in the future

The ought fallacy is another name for the naturalistic fallacy. The naturalistic fallacy is committed when one derives normative conclusions (what ought to do) from positive statements (what is the case), including an observation about what things are universally true about the world.

A person commits the naturalistic fallacy when they say something like “you ought to do X” because they observe that “90% of people do X.”

Is-Ought Fallacy Examples

The statement “I ought to do my homework” is a fallacy because it assumes that the person has control over whether or not they will do their homework.

This is an example of the ought fallacy because it implies that there are some things in life that people have no control over, and so should not be held accountable for them

Is-Ought example in Philosophy

Examples of Is-Ought Fallacy in Philosophy:

The is-ought fallacy is a logical fallacy that occurs when someone argues from the way things are to how they ought to be.

This type of argumentation typically takes one of two forms: either “X is true because we say so” or “X must be done because it’s always been done that way.”

In both cases, X may not actually be true or necessary

Is-Ought Fallacy Real-Life Examples

Is-Ought Fallacy in Real Life:

Is ought fallacy is an error of reasoning in which one party attempts to force, for one reason or another, another party to do something that they otherwise wouldn’t.

This type of fallacy is often employed by parents who think they know what’s best for their children, governmental policies, and religious persons. For example, one parent may say to a child: “You ought to clean your room.” This is an example of an Ought fallacy

Is-Ought Fallacy Examples in Media

Examples of Is-Ought Fallacy in Media: 

•  A TV show says that “you ought to” eat more vegetables.
• A newspaper article says that “you ought to” wear a helmet when riding a bike.
•  An advertisement tells you that “you ought to” buy their product

Is-Ought Examples in Advertising

Is-Ought Fallacy in Advertising: 

The statement “you ought to buy this product” is a fallacy because it assumes that the listener has no other options.

This is an example of the “is-ought fallacy” because it’s not clear whether or not you should buy the product based on what is being said.

It’s important to be aware of these types of fallacies in order to avoid making false assumptions

Other examples include;

•  A billboard advertising a car that says “New Car Smell”
•  An ad for a weight loss supplement featuring before and after pictures of the same person

Is-Ought Fallacy in Politics

Examples of Is-Ought Fallacy in Politics:

The argument that a politician should not be held accountable for his or her actions because they are part of the system.

A false equivalence between two things, typically in order to mislead people into thinking one is as good as another when it isn’t

Is-Ought Fallacy examples in Movies

Examples of Is-Ought Fallacy in Movies:

The movie “The Shawshank Redemption” is an example of the ought fallacy because it has a happy ending, which is not realistic.

In the movie “The Shining,” Jack Torrance becomes violent and abusive to his family, which should not happen in real life.

In the film “Titanic,” Rose’s love for Jack causes her death when she could have saved herself

Is-Ought Fallacy Examples in Literature

Examples of Is-Ought Fallacy in Literature:

The ought-is fallacy is the tendency to derive ought statements from statements of is or to derive ought conclusions from is statements.

For example, a writer may state that men who believe in a woman’s right to choose are evil. The writer may then argue that, because the men believe in a woman’s right to choose, they ought to be treated with the same disdain as people who believe in racism and misogyny.

Is-Ought Fallacy Examples in News

Examples of Is-Ought Fallacy in News:

The news article suggests that the president should not have done what he did.

That is an example of ought fallacy because it assumes that the president could have acted differently

Related Articles:

• Stacking the Deck Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

• 10+ Name Calling Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads