Complex Question Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

Complex Question Fallacy

Complex Question Fallacy Definition

The complex question fallacy is a type of informal fallacy that occurs when someone makes an argument by posing a loaded, usually rhetorical question to the audience and then proceeds to answer it themselves.  It occurs when an interrogator deliberately asks a question to which there is no one answer.

The “complex question” is a form of a deceptive question that attempts to mislead the respondent by giving them an unrelated and meaningless question so that they will answer dishonestly.

The question must be misleading, and the interrogator must not provide the answer. The purpose of this fallacy is to create some confusion.

An example of a complex question fallacy would be asking, “Isn’t it true that he was at the crime scene right before it happened?” in an effort to confuse the person being asked.

The false cause is another fallacy in which the evidence for and against a causal relationship is presented such that the evidence for the correlation strengthens the case for the causal relationship.

This fallacy is a statement that appears to be a question, but it is really an assertion. This type of fallacy is commonly found in debates and in political speeches. The use of this fallacy is sometimes referred to as “leading the witness.” An example of this fallacy is, “Isn’t it true that you didn’t tell the police the truth about your whereabouts?”

The Complex Question Fallacy is a question that’s deceptive because it forces the person answering it to provide a yes or no answer to two separate questions that may have different answers. This fallacy is a common technique in sales, as in, “Do you want the job with more hours but less pay or the one with less hours but more pay?” It’s also often used in debates.

A complex question is a fallacious argument that purports to be a question. Still, it actually includes one or more unproven assumptions and invites a person to accept it as true without providing evidence.

The fallacy should not be confused with a Yes/No question, a speech act in which a question is used as an order or an expression of astonishment.

These are questions that are;

• The question is not a true or false question.
• It is difficult to answer the question because it does not have a yes or no answer.
•  The answer can be found in the passage’s text, but it will take some time and effort to find it.

Complex Question Fallacy Examples

Complex Question example in Philosophy

Examples of Complex Question Fallacy in Philosophy:

For example, “Do you still beat your wife?” or “Can God create a stone too heavy for Him to lift?”

Another form of this fallacy is the loaded-question argument. One asks questions with presupposed conclusions to force their opponent into agreeing with them on some point they have not been able to establish through evidence or valid reasoning.

Complex Question Fallacy Real-Life Examples

Complex Question Fallacy in Real Life:

•  It’s raining outside, so you’re not going to get wet.
•  You can’t be pregnant because you had your period last month

Complex Question Fallacy Examples in Media

Examples of Complex Question Fallacy in Media: 

• The media often reports on a single story or event, which can create the impression that this is the only thing happening in the world.
• A reporter may not always be able to provide all of the information needed for an accurate and complete understanding of a situation.
• Media outlets sometimes use sensational language and images to attract attention from viewers.
• News stories are often oversimplified or incomplete

Complex Question Examples in Advertising

Complex Question Fallacy in Advertising: 

A common example of a complex question fallacy in advertising is the use of a “yes-no” question to elicit a “yes” response.

The following is an example: “Do you want to be more attractive?”.

This type of question assumes that the respondent will answer yes, and as such, does not allow for any other responses.

Complex Question Fallacy in Politics

Examples of Complex Question Fallacy in Politics:

The complex question fallacy is a type of informal fallacy which occurs when the speaker asks two questions in one, such as “Have you stopped beating your wife?”

It can also be used to ask someone to answer a more difficult question by first asking them something easier, such as “What’s 2+2?”

This technique is often used in debates and interviews where the person being interviewed may not have time to think about their response before answering.

Complex Question Fallacy examples in Movies

Examples of Complex Question Fallacy in Movies:

• The movie is a comedy, but the protagonist’s life is in danger.
• The question is too vague.
• The answer does not provide enough information.
•  The answer has been biased by the person giving it.
•  The question is loaded with assumptions that are not true or cannot be proven.

Complex Question Fallacy Examples in Literature

Examples of Complex Question Fallacy in Literature:

1. The question is complex, but the answer is simple.  A fallacy occurs when there are two or more questions in one sentence that have different meanings.

Example of a complex question fallacy in literature:

• “What do you think about the book?”
•  The protagonist is not a reliable narrator.
• The story has multiple narrators.
• There are unreliable narrators in the story

Complex Question Fallacy Examples in News

Examples of Complex Question Fallacy in News:

The article is not clear on what the fallacy is, but it appears to be a question that has an answer of “yes” or “no.”

There are different types of questions that can fall under this category, such as:

– Is there any evidence for global warming?

– Has anyone ever seen Bigfoot?

This type of question often prompts readers to respond with their opinion rather than providing evidence or facts in response.

Related:

• 10 Guilt by Association Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

• Oversimplification Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads

• Rationalization Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads