False Choice Fallacy Examples in Media, Real Life, Politics, News & Ads
False Choice Fallacy
False Choice Fallacy Definition
The False Choice fallacy is a type of logical fallacy in which a person has only presented two choices, and the person is misled to believe that these are the only options. In short, False Choice’s fallacy is the assumption that there are only two options for a decision when in reality, there are more.
This type of logical fallacy is often seen in arguments that deal with things like abortion and gun control. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that renders an argument invalid.
A false choice fallacy is when someone is given a choice between two options that are not equal. This strategy is an argument that does not make sense, and it doesn’t address the question being asked. This tactic is often used by people who want to take charge of the conversation.
False Choice Fallacy is a situation in which someone is presented with a list of options that are not adequate and then told to choose one. In general, the list of options is two extremes on opposite ends of a spectrum.
The fallacy is often used when an individual is presented with two options, and one feels as though they are not being given a middle ground to fall upon.
False Choice Fallacy Examples
False Choice example in Philosophy
Examples of False Choice Fallacy in Philosophy:
An example of this fallacy is when someone is told that they can either choose to eat healthy or eat unhealthy. The fact is that there are other options, such as eating moderately. Another example is when someone is told that they can either be successful or be happy.
False Choice Fallacy Real-Life Examples
False Choice Fallacy in Real Life:
. The most common false choice fallacy is the “black and white” or “either-or” fallacy. This type of fallacy can be seen in politics, where a politician will offer you two options when there are more than two possibilities.
For example, if someone asks for your opinion on abortion and you say that it’s wrong to kill an unborn child, they may respond by saying that you’re either pro-life or pro-choice, but not both.
False Choice Fallacy Examples in Media
Examples of False Choice Fallacy in Media:
- “Do you want to be a hero, or do you want to be liked?”
- “Do you want to save your family from poverty, or do you want them to have better opportunities in life?”
- “Are you going to vote for Trump and get what he wants, or are you going to vote for Clinton and get what she wants?”
False Choice Examples in Advertising
False Choice Fallacy in Advertising:
- “You’re either with us or against us.”
- “If you don’t buy this, then you’ll be sorry.”
- “It’s a fact that if you eat too much sugar, then your teeth will rot out of your head.”
False Choice Fallacy in Politics
Examples of False Choice Fallacy in Politics:
The false choice fallacy is when someone presents two options as the only choices available, even though there are other possibilities.
A false choice can be presented in a number of ways:
- “You’re either with us or against us.”
- “Do you want to live in poverty or wealth?”
- “Do you support our cause or not?”
False Choice Fallacy examples in Movies
Examples of False Choice Fallacy in Movies:
- The protagonist is given two options to choose from, but both choices are equally bad.
- The protagonist has a choice between two things that are both good, but they’re not the same thing.
- A character must choose between something good and something bad
- A person is told that they can either go to the store or watch a movie. The person chooses to go to the store. They are then told that if they had chosen to watch a movie, they would have been able to buy more food for their family.
False Choice Fallacy Examples in Literature
Examples of False Choice Fallacy in Literature:
The false choice fallacy occurs when a person is given two options, but there are more than two possible outcomes.
One example of this type of fallacy in literature is the story “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson.
In the story, people participate in a lottery where they draw stones from a box to see who will be stoned to death.
False Choice Fallacy Examples in News
Examples of False Choice Fallacy in News:
- A news article that presents two opposing viewpoints and then asks the reader to choose one.
- A political candidate who offers a choice between “prosperity or poverty.”